The Best Steak Marinade Recipe - Gonna Want Seconds (2024)

Our easy steak marinade Recipe will help you make your best steak ever! No more relegating steak to special occasion status! Even inexpensive cuts of beef will satisfy you when you use this steak marinade. Fire up your grill, STAT!

This recipe is my favorite Steak Marinade for grilling your favorite cut of beef – it comes together in a flash and works its “science” overnight. Marinating is one of those processes that make you realize just how much science magic happens in the kitchen. I like to use Boneless Beef Loin New York Steak, which can hold its texture just fine in an overnight steak marinade.

I can honestly say I’ve never met a steak I didn’t like, but I have met some that could do with a few hours in a well-constructed marinade. The beauty of the whole marinating process is that you can turn even an inexpensive cut of beef into something worthy of a special occasion, and I’m all for having a little extra “special” in our lives!

The right marinade can make an impenetrable cut of meat sponge-up loads of flavor and yield its tense tissue for a tender result. All that happens because of the chemistry going on between your steak and the marinade.

IF you love steak as much as I do, I hope you’ll try more of our family favorites like Swiss steak, steak pizzaiola, and grilled flank steak.

Why Marinate A Steak

The marinade ingredients are combined to scientifically tenderize it, flavor it, and ultimately caramelize the exterior just a bit!

What’s The Best Way To Tenderize A Steak?

You’ll just need to remember this simple acronym: S-O-F-A.

• Salt: The “S” stands for salt, which is probably the most important ingredient in a marinade for steak, or any other meats, for that matter.
  • Marinades, in general, have a hard time penetrating more than a few millimeters past the surface, but salt helps increase that depth a bit (through a boring but important process similar to osmosis).
  • Salt also helps break down some of the proteins in the meat, ones that typically shrink during the cooking process and leave you wondering how much water you’ll have to drink to digest that dry piece of sawdust on your plate.
  • Breaking down those proteins means more moisture is retained during the cooking process. Plus it’s, well, salt, which enhances even the most naturally flavorful foods. My marinade uses soy sauce to provide the salt as well as an extra savory, umami component.
• Oil: The “O” stands for oil which serves two purposes: it works as a conduit for any flavorings that are only soluble in oil (garlic, one of my favorite “flavorizers,” being one) and helps with consistent browning once the steak hits the grill.
  • Mild, high-smoke-point oils are the preferred choice here for a bbq steak marinade, so I use a regular or light olive oil in the recipe (rather than extra-virgin, for example).
• Flavor: “F” is for flavor, and the sky’s the limit here, but you want to use strong flavors that will stand up to the natural flavor of the beef. I always use garlic and aromatics that have a little bit of gusto. In this Steak Marinade recipe, I’ve added Italian seasoning and pepper (freshly ground, of course), plus some Worcestershire sauce and Dijon mustard to do a little double-duty.
  • They both add tons of flavor (seriously, Worcestershire sauce has like 50 ingredients!), but they also supplement that last mandatory marinade ingredient. “A” is for acid.
• Acid: Whether you use citrus juice, vinegar, or even beer or wine, acid is essential for any marinade. Acid more than any other ingredient works to break down the connective tissue in steak, so it’s your tough cut’s best friend.
  • I use red wine vinegar because I like the flavor, and Worcestershire sauce and mustard bring a little extra vinegar to play as well. It’s important to understand that too much of a good thing can quickly become a bad thing, though, so keep the ratio of oil to vinegar at about 1 to ½ and choose the marinating time carefully. Otherwise, your tough cut will go from tender to mealy, and you might just ruin a steak you’ve spent a small fortune on.

Steak Marinade Ingredients

• Oil: Any neutral flavored oil with a mid to high smoke point will work.
• Soy Sauce: Adds salt and umami.
• Balsamic Vinegar: Adds the acid to tenderize the steak, great flavor and sweetness.
• Red Wine Vinegar: Compliments the balsamic, giving the marinade the proper amount of acid, without making it too sweet.
• Worcestershire sauce: Adds an amazing amount of flavor. It’s a bit tangy, sweet and savory.
• Dijon mustard: Adds great savory flavor.
• Garlic: Please only use fresh garlic for the proper flavor, not the stuff that comes for the jar already minced.
• Italian Seasoning: A great combo of herbs that come already mixed. No need to buy multiple jars of herbs when you grab this!
• Pepper: Black pepper freshly ground finishes off the savory flavor profile.

How Long Do You Marinate Steak?

Beef is like a lot of things: you get what you pay for. To determine how long to marinate steak, you just need to look at the price tag. Expensive prime cuts mean higher quality beef that’s more tender and flavorful and don’t need much fussing over.

For those, you’ll either need a quick steak marinade, with minimal exposure time to the acid you’ve chosen, or a low-acid version for longer, flavor-concentrating.

What Sides Go With Steak?

One of my favorite things to serve with steak is a great, fresh salad! We like cucumber tomato salad, KFC coleslaw,carrot salad, fresh broccoli salad,and/or our spinach strawberry salad!

My family will absolutely want something a little carb-y to round things out! We love three bean salad, corn pudding, au gratin potatoes, funeral potatoes, ranch potatoes, or garlic bread are also solid, yummy choices!

We also like steak paired with one of our great pasta salad recipes. We love our classic macaroni salad, tortellini salad, or dill pickle pasta salad!

Recipe Notes For The Best Steak Marinade:

• Watch your fire: Now that you’ve carefully marinated your steak, you don’t want to overcook it!
  • There’s definitely an art to grilling the perfect steak. The same type of steak can vary in thickness plus the temperature will continue to rise another 5 or 10 degrees once you’ve removed it from the heat. The first thing to remember is to get your steak as close to room temperature as you can before grilling.
  • Remove it from the fridge at least 30 minutes before you plan to start the sizzling. It can be difficult to remember all those ranges for cooking times and temperatures for different degrees of doneness, especially if you’re grilling for a crowd, so here’s a handy graphic to help take the guesswork out of when to pull your steak off the fire:
• Beer Me: For some aficionados’ steak marinade beer needs to come first! Nothing makes better fajitas, right?
  • Feel free to use it in my recipe as a red wine vinegar replacement, and use a little chili powder and cumin instead of the Italian seasoning. I’d suggest a light
  • lager-style, rather than a dark beer, to do its tenderizing duty without competing with the beef flavor.

How to Store

• How Long Can You Keep This In The Fridge?Immediately store leftover beef steak 2 hours after cooking. leftovers can last in the fridge for 3-4 days.
• Can You Freeze This? Leftovers can be stored in the freezer for 2-3 months.
• Food Safety: If you’d like more info on food safety check out this link.

Check Out More Fabulous Steak Recipes!

• Steak Chili – Steak chili is one of those hearty stick-to-your-ribs recipes full of fork-tender meat, veggies, and beans with a secret ingredient to amp up the flavor!
• Steak Sandwich – This is not your average steak sandwich. Juicy ribeye steak, arugula, and roasted garlic mayo make your next steak (sandwich) night the yummiest ever.
• Easy Tropical Flank Steak – Absolutely delicious with an easy-to-make marinade!
• Steak Tacos – Great weeknight meal served with shredded cheese, sour cream, lettuce, and whatever else suits my mood!

Reader Interactions